San Miguel County voters will decide who serves as sheriff in the Nov. 3 general election, the first time in nearly 50 years the office has gone before voters, according to KOTO community radio, which hosted both candidates on its "Off the Record" program Oct. 6.

The candidates are Dan Covault, the incumbent sheriff running as an unaffiliated candidate, and Lane Masters, a Democrat. Covault was appointed by the San Miguel County Board of County Commissioners in April 2025, according to his campaign site, and was sworn in that June following the resignation of longtime sheriff Bill Masters, according to the Telluride Daily Planet. Masters grew up in Telluride, the son of former sheriff Bill Masters, graduated from Telluride High School, served in the Marine Corps, joined the San Miguel County Sheriff's Office in 2023 and now works as a Telluride Marshal deputy, according to KOTO.

Dan Covault, the incumbent sheriff, is running as an unaffiliated candidate in the Nov. 3 general election.
Dan Covault, the incumbent sheriff, is running as an unaffiliated candidate in the Nov. 3 general election.

Covault for Sheriff campaign

At the Oct. 6 KOTO forum, the two candidates discussed community policing, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, and how best to keep the county safe. A week earlier, the Progressive Women's Caucus of the San Juans hosted an election forum with the sheriff candidates alongside county commissioner candidates and supporters of the Telluride School District's ballot measure 5A.

In written responses to the San Miguel Basin Forum's candidate questionnaire, published in September, Covault described his approach this way: "It starts with equal justice for all and to treat everyone like you would treat your grandmother." He wrote that in a small county "today's offender may be tomorrow's victim," adding, "A peacekeeper's job is not to be judge and jury. Our job is to be seekers of the truth, collectors of fact and curators of impartiality." Asked about license plate reader cameras, Covault said the "Flock" label is a brand name being applied too broadly to the technology, and added, "I personally feel that LPR cameras are a valuable tool for peace officers when utilized correctly and with oversight."

Lane Masters, a Democrat, is challenging Covault for San Miguel County sheriff.
Lane Masters, a Democrat, is challenging Covault for San Miguel County sheriff.

KOTO FM

Masters told KOTO his motivation is civic duty and the chance for voters to decide what policing looks like in the county. "I spent 17 years trying to get out of here to spend the next 17 years trying to come back," he said. He aligned himself with his father's approach, saying, "if you liked my father's policies and practices, I'm very similarly aligned," while adding that he brings a more modern view, including technology such as body-worn cameras with live translation so deputies can communicate across language barriers.

What happens next

The 1887 San Miguel County Courthouse in Telluride, pictured during facade restoration. KOTO reports the sheriff's race is the county's first contested vote for the office in nearly 50 years.
The 1887 San Miguel County Courthouse in Telluride, pictured during facade restoration. KOTO reports the sheriff's race is the county's first contested vote for the office in nearly 50 years.

KLOTZ, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Voters will choose between Covault and Masters in the Nov. 3 general election. The winner will lead a sheriff's office that covers a county of just over 8,000 residents, in the words of the incumbent, a place too small and too rural for deputies to be only law enforcement.